Aren’t We Better Off Without Religion?

Religion is a hot topic, isn’t it? Some claim it’s a source of division, while others find deep meaning and purpose in it. In Confronting Christianity, Rebecca McLaughlin poses the provocative question, "Aren’t we better off without religion?" Her answer? Well... it’s complicated.

Let’s dive into her journey to understand the impact of religion—both the good and the not-so-good—and discover how Christianity invites us into a life-giving, transformative way of living.

What is Religion?

Religion is a hot topic, isn’t it? Some claim it’s a source of division, while others find deep meaning and purpose in it. In Confronting Christianity, Rebecca McLaughlin poses the provocative question, "Aren’t we better off without religion?" Her answer? Well... it’s complicated.

Let’s dive into her journey to understand the impact of religion—both the good and the not-so-good—and discover how Christianity invites us into a life-giving, transformative way of living.

How Does Religion Impact Us?

In 2016, a survey of incoming U.S. college freshmen revealed that 30.9% claimed no religious affiliation—a 10% increase from 2006. But does walking away from religion lead to a better life? The research suggests otherwise.

Consider this: those who regularly participate in religious practices tend to have lower rates of depression, greater purpose, and stronger self-control. They are less likely to divorce or commit suicide and often report higher levels of happiness and optimism. Why? Relationships.

Religion fosters deep, meaningful relationships that go beyond surface-level connections. But it’s not just about community. Studies show that community support accounts for less than 30% of religion’s positive effects. Something deeper is at work.

How Did Jesus Defy Religion?

While religion fosters connection, Jesus invites us into something greater: a life-changing relationship with God. Author Jonathan Haidt describes humanity’s basic psychological needs as love, work, and connection to something larger. Christianity offers the most profound version of that "something larger": a visceral connection to God.

Jesus didn’t just conform to the religious systems of His time—He challenged them. He showed us a better way of community and living, rooted not in rules but in love, grace, and purpose.

So, are we better off without religion? As McLaughlin reveals, the answer is both yes and no. Religion, at its best, meets our deepest needs for connection and meaning. And Christianity offers us something even greater: a relationship with the God who created us and calls us to thrive.